The architecture critic Ada Louise Huxtable doesn't much care for Williamsburg. She said to David Gergen on the News Hour with Jim Lehrer: "It's completely synthetic... They destroyed or moved over a hundred buildings that were past what they call that cutoff date, and then they brought other buildings in from other places. And they've--theirs--it's scholarly. It's studious. It's conscientiously done, but it is synthetic." (full interview here) |
It is an easy jump to go from Williamsburg to the exclusively cozy milieus of new towns like Seaside and Celebration (the Disney sponsored community). But the themed environment is hardly a new impulse in America. Think of the great urban parks of Olmsted and Vaux, Jefferson's "academical village," the earlier Florida towns of Opa-Locka and Coral Cables, or even the Getty Museum by Richard Meier, a shining cultural city on the hill, overlooking the sprawl of Los Angeles. |
For another kind of utopia I invite you to look at my photographs of the periphery of Amsterdam. There, the new towns on the polder are built without the slightest gesture to historical pre-war styles. They are architectural theme parks of the new. |